What Criteria Goes Into Recommending a Pistol?

What Criteria Goes Into Recommending a Pistol?

Choosing the right firearm is a critical decision, and at Urban Defense Academy, we understand it’s not a one-size-fits-all process. Making an effective weapon recommendation requires careful consideration of many factors unique to you. Our goal is to arm you with the unbiased knowledge needed to select the gun and equipment that perfectly fits your individual circumstances and self-defense goals.

We pride ourselves on providing impartial guidance because we don’t sell guns or equipment. This allows us to focus solely on empowering you to make the most informed decision.

Key Criteria We Consider:

Before recommending a pistol, we delve into traits that significantly impact your selection:

  • Physique: Hand size (big or small), hand strength (strong or weak).
  • Stance: Your natural posture.
  • Experience Level: Your familiarity with firearms.
  • Practice Commitment: Your willingness to consistently train with and manipulate the weapon.
  • Intended Use: Whether for home defense, concealed carry, recreational shooting, or armed self-defense. Each purpose may influence the ideal gun or caliber.

Navigating Biases and Misconceptions

People often come to us with preconceived notions or biases about specific gun types or calibers. While some beliefs are logically founded, others are not. Our role is to help you cut through the noise.

It’s true that our instructors, including Brian, have their own preferences shaped by their extensive training and lineage of teachers – often favoring large calibers for maximum effect in reliable firearms. However, we ensure these personal biases, like a preference for the 1911 .45 ACP, do not unduly influence your choices. What works for an expert might not be ideal for you, and we recognize that striker-fired weapons, for instance, have made tremendous improvements in their trigger systems recently.

We also acknowledge the overwhelming market. No single person can keep up with every new gun and feature. What’s popular isn’t always ideal, and unfortunately, many poorly designed or dangerous firearms exist. We caution against the “Gun Shop Commando” mentality, as our late instructor Michael Harries called those who push sales over suitability.

And beware the “it feels good” fallacy. Just because a gun feels comfortable in the store doesn’t mean it’s the right choice for you. The best gun is one you can control effectively and accurately, not just one that feels good at first touch.

Ready for a Personalized Recommendation?

Now that you understand the complexities involved in recommending a pistol, you might be eager for “the list” of recommended guns. But we believe in a personalized approach over a generic list.


Instead, we invite you to schedule our Pistol Basics class or Contact Us for a Free Consultation. This allows us to understand your unique needs and guide you to the perfect firearm for your journey.


You may also like...